I looked at Rachel.
"How long were you together?"
She hesitated.
"We were already seeing each other in March. On March eighth, he told me he loved me."
I stared at Gary.
"He was still living with you then?"
"That was our anniversary."
Rachel went still.
"He was still living with you then?"
"Yes. He told me he had a work dinner."
Rachel looked at him.
I remembered the dinner I'd eaten by myself that night. I'd saved him a plate in the refrigerator.
"You told me you'd spent that evening alone before coming to see me."
Gary stared at the pavement.
I remembered the dinner I'd eaten by myself that night. I'd saved him a plate in the refrigerator.
Now I wondered how many ordinary little kindnesses he'd accepted while telling someone else I was a terrible wife.
"Debbie," Gary began.
"Look, Rachel was controlling. Always checking where I went, asking questions."