Watching my grandchildren chase each other around the rose bushes we’d planted together that spring, their laughter carrying across the same porch Daniel and Renee had once imagined for their own morning coffee, I thought about how close I’d come to simply accepting that dinner table question without ever asking myself what I actually deserved after thirty-eight years of marriage and two years of quiet, uncompensated service to a household that had forgotten to see me clearly.
“Happy birthday, Dad,” I said quietly, raising a glass of lemonade toward the sky as the sun began setting behind the oak trees. “I think you’d be proud of how this all turned out, even the parts that hurt getting here.”