I looked at his photograph.
“You could have called me,” I said, though he was no longer there to answer.
The letter seemed to answer for him.
I should have called. I told myself I was giving you time. Then I told myself you were happier without the weight of my disappointment. Eventually, I was ashamed that so much time had passed, and shame made every day of silence harder to break.
Arthur lowered his head.
“I urged him to contact you,” he said. “Several times.”
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
“Because I believed Robert had the right to tell you himself.”
I nodded slowly. No one had intended for silence to last twelve years. That was perhaps what made it unbearable. It had grown through a series of choices, each one small enough to defend, until the distance became a wall.
I read the final page.
Six weeks before I died, I found the courage to ask your mother for the truth. She admitted that she had not sent your letters. She also admitted that when you called after your first deployment, she told you I was asleep, though I was sitting beside her.