Colds. Strep. School plays. Two cakes every birthday because Grace wanted chocolate and Emily wanted vanilla and I was not going to be the man who made them share.
After the Case Closed, Andrea Gave Me the Towels Back
She mailed them. There was a note that said These belong with them.
I put them in a cedar box on the top shelf of my closet with a few other things.
Sarah’s photo I kept in my wallet, behind my license.
And Ivy’s name I kept quiet.
That was a decision. I want to be clear that it was a decision and not an accident. I made it early and I held it for eighteen years, and I made it because I believed a boy’s logic:
If I don’t say her name, my daughters will never wonder whether they’re standing in someone else’s place.
Then They Turned Fifteen and the Secrets Started
“We’re staying after to study.”