That’s the honest thing.
I’d been rehearsing it in the shop with the radio on. Imagining the conversation. Deciding what my face would do. Working out how to say I think that’s wonderful and have it sound true.
I cooked their favorites that night. Garlic chicken and mashed potatoes with too much butter.
Chris came by with a cake and hugged them both hard. Andrea called, the way she has every single birthday for eighteen years.
When Chris left, he wouldn’t meet my eyes at the door.
That should have told me something.
After dinner, Emily set down her fork.
“Dad, we need to go get something.”
Grace stood up too fast, and her chair caught the tile.
They went upstairs together and I sat at that table listening to their footsteps overhead and thinking: here it comes.
“For Three Years, We’ve Been Lying to You”
They came back down with the towels.
“Dad,” Emily said. “Please don’t hate us for what you’re about to see.”