Sophie played music while Grace chopped vegetables.
Lily complained about the dishes.
Emma set five plates on the table.
Five.
The same number we’d used for 15 years.
After dinner, Emma brought out an old purple notebook.
Its cover showed a faded unicorn.
“I found this last month.”
I recognized it.
“Your seventh birthday.”
She smiled.
“I kept it because you gave it to me.”
I touched the worn cover.
“I’m sorry I couldn’t buy you the toy.”
Emma shook her head.
“Mom, I never needed the giant one.”
She looked around the kitchen.
“You gave us everything that mattered.”
My daughters gathered around me.
And I let myself cry.
Richard eventually sent a letter acknowledging the money he’d taken.
He enclosed a small payment and promised to continue repaying us.
I didn’t mistake it for redemption.
Emma chose not to answer his messages.
Lily needed time.
Sophie agreed to occasional conversations.
Grace wanted no contact.