But by the time she left Daniel, shame had done what his lie had started. It kept her away.
Back home that evening, Emma picked up the bundle of birthday letters.
“Can we read them?”
“They’re yours,” I said.
We sat on the living room floor like the girls used to when they were small, and they read them in order.
On their first birthday, Vanessa wrote about buying three cards and sitting in her car outside the post office, unable to go in.
On their fifth, she described seeing a set of triplets in a grocery store and crying in the parking lot for an hour afterward.
On their tenth, she wrote that she had found their school’s website and a photograph of Sophie holding a science fair trophy.
Sophie stopped reading. “She was watching us?”
Claire opened the twelfth.
“I finally learned the truth about the letter this year. I hired someone to find you. I know your address now. I know where you go to school. I know your father never remarried.”